On this page 6 sections
Choosing a private label skincare manufacturer is the one decision in a launch that is expensive to reverse. Your formulas, your regulatory file and your first stock all sit with them. Change manufacturer after launch and you can be re-sampling, re-testing and re-printing everything you have already paid for once.
So it is worth an afternoon of questions before you pay a deposit. Below are the twelve we would ask if we were on your side of the table, what a good answer sounds like, and the red flags that should end the conversation. They work for any manufacturer in Pakistan, including us.
Before you start: know which route you want
Private label, white label and custom formulation are different services, and a manufacturer can be excellent at one and weak at another. Private label puts your brand on a proven formula you can adjust. White label is the same stock product sold unchanged to many brands. Custom formulation develops something new to your brief. If you are not sure which fits, read our comparison of the three routes first, because several questions below have different right answers depending on the route.
The 12 checks
1. Do they manufacture, or do they broker?
Not every company that advertises as a manufacturer runs its own production. Some resell another factory's white label stock, which is not wrong in itself, but it means the people answering your questions are not the people making your product. Ask where the filling happens, and ask to meet the team that will formulate and produce your range.
2. Can you check their certificates?
A logo on a website is not a certificate. Ask for copies of the Halal and ISO certificates showing the certifying body, the certificate number, the scope and the expiry date, and check them with the body that issued them. The scope matters: a certificate that covers a different site or a different activity does not cover your product.
3. Who handles DRAP, and do your products even need it?
A plain moisturiser or cleanser with only cosmetic claims sits under PSQCA and the relevant Pakistan Standard. Medicated and derma-care products and oral supplements are enlisted with DRAP's Health and OTC Products Division. A good manufacturer classifies each product before formulating it, tells you which route applies, and explains who will hold the enlistment. Our DRAP enlistment guide walks through the steps.
4. How is each batch tested?
Ask what is tested, by whom, and what you receive. The answer you want names an independent laboratory such as PCSIR, includes stability data for your formula and pack, and gives you a certificate of analysis with every batch. See what PCSIR testing actually covers.
5. Will they sample before you commit?
You should be able to see, feel and test each product before placing a production order, and ask for changes until you are happy with it. Ask whether samples are charged, how many rounds of revisions are included, and whether a sample fee is set against your first order.
6. Will they show you what is in the jar?
Ask for the full ingredient list (the INCI list) of every product before you commit. It goes on your label, so you will see it eventually anyway. A manufacturer who will not share it early is asking you to stand behind a product you have not been allowed to read.
7. Who owns the formula, and is it exclusive?
On private label, the formula normally stays the manufacturer's, and the same base may be sold to other brands with different fragrance, colour or texture. On custom formulation, ownership is negotiable. Neither is a problem as long as it is agreed in writing before development starts. The expensive mistake is assuming an exclusivity you never agreed.
8. What is the minimum order, exactly?
Ask whether the MOQ is per product, per pack size or per order. Minimums usually apply per product and per pack size, so a five-product range in two sizes can mean ten minimums. Ask for the minimum on reorders too, which can differ from the first order.
9. Who designs and prints the packaging?
Packaging often costs more than the formula inside it, and a label with a missing line has to be reprinted. Ask whether printing is in-house or outsourced, who checks the artwork against the labelling requirements, and who carries the cost if a required line is missed.
10. Will they put the quote and the dates in writing?
You want an itemised quote that separates formulation, manufacturing, primary packaging, printing and testing, with dated stages and a validity period. A manufacturer who commits to dates in writing is telling you something useful about how they work. One who will only give a single rounded figure over the phone is telling you something too.
11. What happens if something goes wrong with a batch?
Ask about batch records, retained samples and how complaints are handled. If a customer reports a reaction six months from now, you need to know which batch they used and what it contained. Batch records under GMP make that answer take minutes, not weeks.
12. Who will you actually talk to?
Ask for a named person who will manage your project from consultation to delivery. The question sounds soft, but most launch delays are communication delays: an unanswered question about a label or an unapproved sample can hold a whole production run.
Red flags that should end the conversation
- No way to meet the team or see where the product is made.
- Promises of "DRAP approved" products, or claims such as "treats acne" or "whitening in seven days" printed on your label. Treatment claims can move a product to a different regulator.
- No ingredient list before you pay.
- Pressure to place a large order before you have approved a sample.
- A single price with no breakdown, and no dates in writing.
- The same product, in the same pack, already on sale under several other brand names.
The checklist at a glance
| Check | What a good answer looks like |
|---|---|
| Manufacture or broker | Their own production, and you can meet the people making your product |
| Certificates | Copies with body, number, scope and expiry that you can verify |
| DRAP | Each product classified before formulation; clear on who holds the enlistment |
| Testing | Independent laboratory, stability data, a certificate of analysis per batch |
| Samples | Samples of every product, revisions until you approve |
| Ingredients | The INCI list before you commit |
| Formula ownership | Ownership and exclusivity agreed in writing before development |
| MOQ | Clear per product and per pack size, for first orders and reorders |
| Packaging | Artwork checked against labelling rules, printing responsibility clear |
| Quote | Itemised, dated stages, with a validity period |
| Batch problems | Batch records, retained samples, a complaints process |
| Contact | One named person from consultation to delivery |
How we answer these at Dermis & Dosis
We would rather you ask us all twelve than none. The short version:
- Certified and tested: Halal and ISO certified, DRAP enlisted, PCSIR tested, with GMP practices on every batch. See our certifications.
- Samples first: samples of each product to see, feel and test, with revisions included until you approve.
- Low minimums: 500 pieces per product for catalogue formulas.
- Packaging under one roof: labels and cartons are designed and printed in-house, and checked against the labelling rules for your category.
- In writing: an itemised quote with dated stages, valid for 30 days.
- Come and see: book a tour of our Lahore facility and walk through formulation, filling, quality control and the printing unit.
If you are comparing manufacturers now, book a free consultation and bring this list. Or send your product list through the quote form, and we will reply with a breakdown you can hold up against anyone else's.
Questions founders ask
Is a private label manufacturer the same as a white label supplier?
No. A white label supplier sells the same finished product, unchanged, to many brands. A private label manufacturer makes a proven formula for your brand, with room to adjust fragrance, texture, colour and pack, and usually handles testing and packaging as well.
Do I need my own DRAP registration?
It depends on the product. Plain cosmetics sit under PSQCA rather than DRAP. For medicated, derma-care and oral products that need enlistment, the manufacturer usually holds the product enlistment, while you hold the trademark and the private label agreement. Your manufacturer should tell you which applies to each product before formulation starts.
How many manufacturers should I compare?
Two or three is enough to calibrate. Send each the same product list and quantities so the quotes are comparable, and judge them on the twelve checks above as well as on price.
